Reply to "Redundant/invalid niches - report them here"

Please read Niche titles and descriptions carefully.

If a Niche is poorly written and gets approved... it's "approval" is a testimony to the efficacy and quality of (to borrow @Ted's language) "The Wisdom of This Crowd."

And, there are some Niches getting upvoted that should not. 

Here are a few from my perusing of the ballots this morning. I try and always leave a comment when I vote no in order to help clarify the thinking behind my vote. 

Beta Testing
https://alpha.narrative.org/hq...al/12716610878367493

These next three are all submitted by @yousaf1981 and all exhibit the same behavior. Submitting a Niche, and a poorly written definition of the title word instead of describing the type of content that it would contain. These are all three passing with overwhelming support. Check your work, people.

prediction
https://alpha.narrative.org/hq...al/12575872447897609

success
https://alpha.narrative.org/hq...al/11168345952844470

celebration
https://alpha.narrative.org/hq...al/11309083456079189

Allowing a Niche to be submitted with only a definition (no matter how poorly/eloquently it is written) for a description... then we're heading towards reinventing the dictionary. 

×
×
×
×