Tagged With "Comments"

Reply

Re: Reputation scores

MOLLY O ·
I am going to close this Question. @blueeyes8960 Thanks for being here and contributing on the Narrative platform. Not sure you have seen our spec - thought that you might find interesting if you hadn't seen it yet.
Reply

Re: Display number of comments with direct link to comments section

Colleen Ryer ·
Yes, this any more brainstorming on how to make commenting really fun and easy to use, keep track of - to keep community interaction way up there
Reply

Re: View of like and unlike and key answer comments to comment in sub-folders of comments.

Vico Biscotti ·
Agree for upvotes notification, and already posted this: https://community.narrative.or...ications-on-up-votes Also, the "reply" button would be important. Downvotes are okay to remain anonymous, in my opinion.
Reply

Re: Remove Vote and Editing Notification on Post/Comment

MALAY BANERJEE ·
This is a wonderful idea. Thanks for sharin. I think narrative organization should think about it.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

MALAY BANERJEE ·
Thanks for sharing the issue because many times correct links didn't appear in middle of the post and comments too.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

David Dreezer ·
I'm not seeing an issue with broken links. Yes, the appearance of the link is shortened for very long links, but if you click them, they work fine. If you want to copy a link - instead of highlighting and copying the text, and right click and choose copy link address, or whatever your browser terms it as. On mobile (chrome is all I have) it's link press on the link and press copy link address. Someone else will have to tell us how it's on on an iPhone.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
@David Dreezer , it occasionally happens. I've not found what triggers it. Of course, I put the full link, in the comment, not the text, but sometimes the text still becomes a link (with the "...") but it's a broken link. I've a clear example, but I can't put a link to a comment (oh, that's a suggestion...), so I can give you only the link of the story https://www.narrative.org/post...-don-ts-on-narrative and a screenshot of the comment If I go in edit, the link is intact.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

David Dreezer ·
Every comment has a direct permalink. Mouse over the date/time on the comment under the commentor's name. This comment is https://www.narrative.org/post...nt=49310581546690363
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
Oh! Didn't notice that... Great. Not that evident, but good to know.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
@David Dreezer , it just happened again, the broken link in a comment. https://www.narrative.org/post...nt=49310581547398708 Seems impossible to avoid it.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

David Dreezer ·
Vico, did you type that link, or copy and paste that link?
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
Copied and pasted the entire url, @David Dreezer .
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

David Dreezer ·
I am completely unable to replicate this in any of my attempts to do so. https://www.narrative.org/post...nt=49310581547406749
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

David Dreezer ·
Jut to be clear, you went to this topic , copied the URL from the address bar in your browser, and pasted it onto your comment?
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
@David Dreezer , yes, copied and pasted from the address bar. So, clean text, no HTML in it. Funny thing is that in edit mode, I get the correct url again: As soon as I submit, the link goes broken again.
Reply

Re: Links doesn't work in post comments

David Dreezer ·
Your links in the original copy/paste that you're posting to all new users do work. The appearance of the links are shorted to prevent page stretch. If people click the links they work fine. If they copy/past them they will not. When you then edit your comment with the shortened links, copying and pasting the shortened link back into your edited post, will cause them to break. When you edit a comment with links you'll need to make sure that you're not pasting a shortened link back into your ...
Reply

Re: Links doesn't work in post comments

BloggerKrunal ·
Hello @David Dreezer Actually I have it in my notes and I copy from it everytime. I don't know when I had copied from the comment and edited my notes with it as I can still see the full links in my notes. But I'll pull the fresh links in my notes now. Hope it works!
Reply

Re: Paragraphs spacing in comments

Ted ·
Hi Vico- I'm not quite understanding the issue. Can you be a bit more clear about what you are experiencing and how to reproduce it? Thanks!
Reply

Re: Paragraphs spacing in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
Sure, @Ted ! To go straight to the point, I'm speaking about the margin-bottom property of the paragraph ( <p> ). This is one of my comments: I added a blank line between paragraphs. If I didn't, the comment would have looked like this: But this is not what I want because in some cases, especially with long comments, the comment becomes a blob, with no visual distinction between paragraphs. But adding a blank line is excessive and can make confusion between multiple comments, and it's...
Reply

Re: Paragraphs spacing in comments

Ted ·
Thanks for clarifying things so well, Vico! We agree that things would be improved with less space between the paragraphs in comments. We plan to improve that in a future update.
Reply

Re: Paragraphs spacing in comments

Vico Biscotti ·
Maybe a typo, @Ted ? I didn't mean LESS space... the contrary! Now we have to manually ADD that space, by adding an extra blank line. It should be avoided, letting some space between paragraphs being there by style (css), as it already happens in posts.
Reply

Re: Broken links in comments

Ted ·
Definitely a bug, Vico. We've added that to our bug list.
Reply

Re: Remove Vote and Editing Notification on Post/Comment

Malkazoid ·
I can see why you suggested this! This has happened to me a couple of times, where I changed my mind and wanted to withdraw my upvote, and just leave it as no vote. I think the difficulty with this may lie in how rewards are computed. If you withdraw your vote after the rewards have been paid out, does the writer then owe the platform a small amount of money to be deducted from the next earnings? Could get messy...
Reply

Re: Remove Vote and Editing Notification on Post/Comment

Vico Biscotti ·
@BloggerKrunal , I agree on the possibility of removing votes. But @Malkazoid is right about rewards. In my opinion, after rewards have been calculated, the removing of the vote could anyway be useful. Of course, not for changing rewards, but for influencing quality metrics (of the post and of the author) and visibility. The edit notification can be tricky. A single word may be enough to change the meaning, so should fire the notification anyway, as it happens in the community. But it could...
Reply

Re: Cannot post comments because you are Conduct Negative

Patrick ·
I've added it to our list of issues. Thanks for letting us know @Malkazoid
Reply

Re: Cannot post comments because you are Conduct Negative

David Dreezer ·
This issue has been fixed now.
Reply

Re: Content Entrepreneur: community forum

Garden Gnome Publications ·
Can you do that automatically, or is there a special trick?
Reply

Re: Content Entrepreneur: community forum

Emily Barnett ·
I just added manually and then created a hyper link to this page. Kind of a pain, but I think worth it. I have a few end steps I take for all of my posts that sort of brand my content...this will be one of them.
Reply

Re: Emojis in comments are broken when I edit the comment.

David Dreezer ·
This issue should be fixed now, with today's update. No more broken smily. Thanks for reporting it.
Reply

Re: Narrative Suggestion Box

David Dreezer ·
Thank you for posting this. There are a lot of suggestions here! Because each suggestion deserves to stand on its' own merit, what I am going to do is close this topic, then create a new suggestion topic for each of the individual suggestions in this list (barring duplicates, of course). Each suggestion will be able to have its' own discussion, tracking, and more importantly, each one can be voted up or down independently. With them all in a large group like this things get lost, missed, and...
Reply

Re: Narrative Suggestion Box

David Dreezer ·
Feel free to please follow through some of these items as I create them and expand a little. These bullet points are a little on the sparse side.
Reply

Re: Narrative Suggestion Box

David Dreezer ·
I'm adding in the links to this topic as I create the suggestion topics for you.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

David Dreezer ·
Noting that this is possibly related to https://community.narrative.or...ions-on-the-platform
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

Vico Biscotti ·
Well, I'm reporting something different. @Gosia Rokicka suggests a notification button on the website, in the suggestion you mention, while I ask to be notified (optionally even by email) when someone comments on my posts or niche submissions.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

David Dreezer ·
good point. Updated.
Reply

Re: Narrative Suggestion Box

David Dreezer ·
@freedom I have created individual suggestions for almost all of these. Nice list. Any bullet item with no link (or the word Dupe) is an item that I just couldn't understand what is being asked. Please repost them separately with some explanation as to what you're asking for. Remember, it's tough to consider building a feature if we don't know what it is or how it works. The more descriptive the better. Hopefully all of these new suggestions that have been posted will get lots of discussion...
Reply

Re: Comment url

David Dreezer ·
Already done. Every comment already has a direct link to the comment. The line with the date/time is a direct link to the individual comment.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

Vico Biscotti ·
News on this? This is still an annoying issue. Many members still don't get, or remember, that they have to mention in the comments, or their comment can go lost in the eyes of the author. Or it's easy to miswrite.
Reply

Re: Possibility to see comments in the author's profile

Vico Biscotti ·
No, @Former Member. I mean something like this (my Medium profile): https://medium.com/@vicobiscotti/responses .
Reply

Re: Possibility to see comments in the author's profile

Vico Biscotti ·
I get that Narrative is different. Maybe being able to see only your own comments, in private, can be a first useful step. On Medium there's much less opportunity of retaliation and of gaming the system, so having the possibility of seeing comments is only useful. Here, honestly I don't know for certain, but I would appreciate. Server resources, very little. Not an issue. Comments are already there. Only some garnish is needed.
Reply

Re: Possibility to see comments in the author's profile

Colleen Ryer ·
HI @Vico Biscotti Medium's commenting I found to be a mess, with comments all mixed together with posts and no way to sort them out. Anyone using RSS (which I really hope to see here ,) especially for promotion, might not want comments in their feed, but get stuck with it anyway - so if comments are to be accessible, I think should be separate from posts, and in light of what @Former Member of misuse potential, maybe only our own comments should be viewable, by our selves.
Reply

Re: Possibility to see comments in the author's profile

Vico Biscotti ·
@Colleen Ryer , Medium has a very poor interface, in terms of sorting/filtering, but I hope Narrative will be different. Personally, I'm fine with comments on Medium but I know it's not so for everybody. Anyway, of course, I intended to have the comment list separated from posts. A different tab in the profile (and not in the feed, at least not by default).
Reply

Re: Nested Comments

Christina Gleason ·
@David Dreezer has referred people to this suggestion from here: https://community.narrative.or...nted-comment-replies But as @Former Member has pointed out, we have had no communication from the Team about this issue.
Reply

Re: Nested Comments

Christina Gleason ·
I'd missed that nested comments were even in the latest HQ article. It's so hard to keep track.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

Ted ·
Yes, we are aware that notifications in general need improvement. It's on our road map. Remember, we are still in Beta! Thanks for your suggestion.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

David Dreezer ·
As this is more of a Suggestion than an Issue ticket I will recategorize it as such. We consider Issues to be along the lines of "this isn't working as intended, there is a bug here."
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

Vico Biscotti ·
I understand what you mean, @David Dreezer . Please consider that I labeled this as an issue because on any content platform bloggers are used to be notified on comments (or to have the opportunity of turning it on/off). In fact, members have adopted the mentioning habit as a workaround. Having to check your past articles for comments is perceived as an issue. Anyway, I get it and it doesn't make much difference.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

David Dreezer ·
@Vico Biscotti what we are looking for in Issue tickets , especially during the beta period, are implemented features that are not working properly. "I turned on Italics and all my print turned green." I made that up, obviously, as an illustration. Features that we acknowledge to be on the Road Map, but have not yet been implemented would not be what we could consider as being an Issue type of ticket.
Reply

Re: Notifications on comments

Vico Biscotti ·
Got it.
×
×
×
×